The game can be played up to 24-turns, but we ended up going for only four with a pretty clear indication of Vercingetorix being able to make it off the table - which is the victory condition for the Gauls. Although the evenly spaced placement of Roman forces by Kimo around the perimeter of the outer barricades seemed to make sense, it ended up being their downfall. It soon became evident, that the use of more centrally-staged Quick Reaction Forces would have been better.
Early on the Gauls inside fortress Alesia had half their forces, along with Vercingetorix, swiftly move southwards for a breakout. As the Romans were spread thinly throughout the outer perimeter, they only had a small force in the southern area. This area is also the first area which off-board relieving Gauls can enter (Turn 1), which they did.
Maybe if Vercingetorix had the same view as I did, he would've made it out too. |
Image from the old National Geographic Greece and Rome book - depicting Caesar's cavalry leading a desperate, and successful, counter attack. |
I'm quite sure we missed some of the details of the rules, but for the most part it played very smoothly and was quite an enjoyable first time for me with a board game. As the game is borrowed from a buddy, I'll likely look for a set on ebay in the future. I have to say the counters make sense, but they are a bit fiddly to move around - particularly when the units get pressed together in close combat.
Great to see such a classic on your game table.
ReplyDeleteFunny (or sad) commentary regarding your Hawaiian maths education. Glad the two of you persevered with the combat ratios.
Are you planning more boardgame play? You know, I am in Renton for work one week per month. Perhaps, we could get together for a game one evening after work sometime? I could pack along my Commands & Colors: Ancients in 6mm.
Thanks, Jonathan. Wow, I knew your work brought you over this way, but didn't know it's for a week at a time, and in Renton. I'll contact you via email. Dean
DeleteGlad to see an AH game, so many souvenirs for me...
ReplyDeleteHappy to hear that, Phil. It is indeed a vintage game - looks like it was printed/published in 1976 or so. Regards, Dean
DeleteNot one i've tried myself it does look cool if a little cramped.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the visit and comment, Simon. I think a multi-player game with two other players might make it pretty cool too - attacking from multiple side - I tend to focus on a particular area when gaming myself. Best, Dean
DeleteOne of the classic AH games - I remember playing many games of Alesia in high school during the late '70's and most always went down to the wire
ReplyDeleteDon't forget the automatic win for the Romans for a 2:1 surround attack!
Thanks for that, Miles. I think in our game, the Romans never were able to surround attack the Gauls - although the Gauls managed it a few times. I can see the usefulness of the Optional Rules once you become familiar with the basics. Regards, Dean
DeleteNever mind the maths, how did you find the layout of the rulebook? Avalon Hill produced some great games but the rulebooks were always a challenge to get through. If you want a more up to date take on ancients gaming try the Command & Colours series, really very enjoyable.
ReplyDeleteBest HGA.
I found the 7 pages of rules to my tastes. The only thing I found a bit much, and that's just me, is the Combat Table for HTH resolution. As you know from my simplification of Hail Caesar - I like something you can pretty much remember without a chart. More like a the results in DBA? Anyway, your suggestion for C&C echoes Jonathan's. Warm regards, Dean
DeleteHaving painted for almost 20 years, but only gamed with the minis for the last 3 years, I'm also slowly starting to look into the joys of military board games. I find them quite inspirational for painting projects, and perhaps useful as campaign generators for a string of miniature-based games. History is fun to replay either way!
ReplyDeleteSoren: Appreciate your visit and thoughts. I too have gamed a fraction of the time compared to painting. I think this board game provides some great ideas which can be translated to a miniatures game. Unless 1:1 skirmish type games, most miniatures are representational like the counters for this game. Best, Dean
DeleteOh! Great to see this Classic alive in the XXI century. I still own a much battered copy from the 80s
ReplyDeleteI was pleasantly surprised to find this borrowed copy in almost pristine condition - one of the three map boards was a slightly warped, but could probably be straightened out - just didn't want to take the chance of damaging it. Otherwise a very well-playing game. Regards, Dean
DeleteI never got a chance to play this one, but I did play AH's Alexander the Great quite a bit. GMT games has an updated game about Alesia in the Great Battles of History series (which I still need to get to the table). Great to see this one all set up!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Greg. I saw the GMT version too. Maybe someday. Thus one was quite enjoyable. Regards, Dean
DeleteAvalon Hill produced some great games way back. I came close to getting this once myself, I did get Caesers Legions which covered a number of Germanic battles at the Julio-Claudians.
ReplyDeleteKen: Thanks for stopping by the blog and posting the cool comments. I think I can now find similar stuff on ebay (or the like) without being totally clueless as to board games. Regards, Dean
Delete